Monday, December 4, 2023
 
 

EU-Turkey earthquake relief conference: Time to get serious

EU Civil Protection website

- Advertisement -

The European Union is hosting a reconstruction conference in Brussels on March 20 to focus on the aftermath of Turkey’s devastating February 6 earthquakes, which killed more than 50,000, including 6,000 in neighboring Syria.

The conference will bring together representatives from EU countries, other major world economies and international financial institutions. 

This comes only a few days after the European Parliament, supposedly deep in structural reform mode after recent scandals, held its own conference to focus attention on the massive earthquake reconstruction requirements. 

While Turkey’s GDP grew by 5.6 percent in 2022, the country’s inflation-ridden economy is now projected to grow in 2023 at 2.0-2.5 percent less than in pre-quake GDP estimates. Early World Bank estimates place the quakes’ physical damage at equivalent to 4 percent of Turkey’s GDP but have since been adjusted upward to 9 percent for 2023.

Assessments of the funding needed for reconstruction are still in the early phases, but at least $45-$50 billion will be needed to meet President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s stated plans to complete reconstruction of 400,000 residences within a year for the approximately 1.5 million left homeless by the quakes, a figure that does not include the large refugee population currently in Turkey.

The actual objective will obviously require much higher amounts, not to mention an adjustment of the impossible one-year target. Erdogan’s government has set up a special off budget mechanism to handle reconstruction requirements without utilizing standard parliamentary budget reviews.

Delegations are en route to Brussels. Our hope is that whatever arrangements are worked out guarantee that after international reconstruction aid begins to flow, Turkey will undertake to become a positive regional force, meaning becoming a good neighbor.  This will require sweeping changes in the foreign and defense policies of pre-earthquake Turkey, but there is little evidence of this so far.

To achieve this result, which is clearly a win-win for all involved, it makes little sense to take final decisions on medium- and long-term reconstruction packages until Turkey’s May 14-28 election cycle is completed. Only then will donors have a sense of what kind of Turkey their taxpayer funded assistance monies will be used to reconstruct.

The list of Western requests to Ankara is long, but one item that is critical in guaranteeing that Turkey becomes a good neighbor would be a reduction of its defense spending and shifting a substantial amount of those resources into reconstruction.

In view of complicated negotiations over NATO expansion, which Ankara is holding up, Western policymakers may be afraid to state their views/demands publicly, but the reconstruction conference provides the ideal mechanism to convince Turkey to cut its defense expenditures from current levels of around 2.06 percent of GDP (2021 data) to something lower. 

It is not a rhetorical question to ask what use Turkey could have for its new drone carrying aircraft carrier when so much of its population is living in tents and container cities, except possibly as a cargo transport or temporary residence.  

Western taxpayers should demand their assistance for reconstruction of Turkey’s devastated southeast provinces not be used to subsidize continued military adventurism on the part of Erdogan’s government.

It’s time to get creative about aid conditionality, perhaps incentivizing Ankara with matching reconstruction grants for every lira shifted out of the defense budget or at least away from new military hardware procurement that threatens regional stability.   

Late note:  The EU announced the conference generated donor pledges of €7.0 billion, compared to the cost of reconstructing destroyed housing now estimated by Turkey at close to €95 billion, almost double earlier figures.  Syria was not invited to the conference, reconstruction costs there are estimated to be at least €13 billion; the EU is currently providing only humanitarian assistance. 

 

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

The Negroni Diaries reflect the views of the author but act chiefly as the official opinion section of NE Global's staff. As part of our effort to provide an unvarnished window into the intricacies of international affairs, this column was so named as nearly all of the world's most pressing issues are regularly discussed in a free and open forum, without the inhibitions of political correctness and revisionist cultural revolutionary-ism, in a setting that is often befitting of the famed Italian cocktail.

Latest

Don't miss

Africa will watch the DRC’s elections with bated interest

2023 and 2024 are going to be busy years...

Ukraine, Middle East will dominate Cameron’s UK foreign policy agenda

David Cameron, who was made Foreign Secretary in a...

What will it take to prevent a Gaza reconstruction fiasco?

Let us be unequivocal about the current war between...

Ukraine’s persecuted mayor

Lest it be forgotten, the major thematic issue in...

Ukraine, Middle East will dominate Cameron’s UK foreign policy agenda

David Cameron, who was made Foreign Secretary in a surprise move by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak during his cabinet reshuffle on November 13, is...

What will it take to prevent a Gaza reconstruction fiasco?

Let us be unequivocal about the current war between Israel and the Palestinian terrorist organization Hamas - the latter declared this war on Israeli...

Ukraine’s persecuted mayor

Lest it be forgotten, the major thematic issue in post-Maidan and pre-war Ukraine was, and continues to be, the transformation of Ukrainian society along...

Cameron’s return as Foreign Secretary raises UK’s international profile

David Cameron, who was made foreign secretary in a surprise move by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak during his cabinet reshuffle on November 13, brings...

Russia’s powerful economic levers over Armenia

Armenia's relations with its strategic partner Russia are getting worse and worse and its leaders seem to desire a shift in geopolitical orientation towards the West....

Economy Minister says Kazakhstan to expand investment and diversify trade with Europe

Kazakhstan’s Minister of National Economy, Alibek Kuantyrov, spoke to NE Global in an exclusive interview about his country's relations with Europe, Astana's economic partners,...

Meeting conditions for Georgia’s EU accession is a tall order for Tbilisi

The European Commission’s provisional endorsement of Georgia’s EU chances contained a not-so-subtle message couched in diplomatic jargon: Tbilisi must forge a stronger national consensus...

New US actions against corruption and Russian malign influence in the Western Balkans

On November 16, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control, known by its acronym OFAC, designated eight individuals and six...