Saturday, April 1, 2023
 
 

Germany approves Nord Stream-2 as issue over Ukrainian transit lingers

Russia would be willing to continue to supply gas to the Ukrainian pipeline in addition to Nord Stream-2 if that improved its position with the EU, analyst says

- Advertisement -

Gazprom’s Nord Stream-2 received the first construction permit from Germany last week as Berlin sees a direct pipeline from Russia as a step towards improving the energy security of one of Europe’s biggest economies.

Chris Weafer, a partner at Macro-Advisory in Moscow told New Europe, that both Nord Stream-2, which will bypass Ukraine from the north, and Turkish Stream in the south “are more likely than not because the recent explosion in Austria and the problems of supply in the UK and Norway in the North Sea, make both projects more likely than less”.

“It just reminded people that Europe is still vulnerable when it comes to energy. I certainly think that in any case, even before those recent outages, both pipelines were more likely simply because the big European countries, particularly Germany and Italy, which are the most dependent on imported energy of the big countries, they want these pipelines,” Weafer said. “That’s the bottom line. No matter what Brussels says or the smaller transit countries say, the big economies want energy security and for them energy security is having a direct pipeline. The Germans made this very clear with Nord Stream 1,” he said. “They were critical of Russia’s actions with Ukraine in 2006 and 2009 and were critical of Gazprom’s actions,” Weafer said, adding that nevertheless “despite European politics and objections from Brussels they built Nord Stream-1 to improve their energy security. I don’t think this has changed,” Weafer added.

Some EU countries, especially Poland and the Baltic states, and the United States oppose Nord Stream-2. US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson reportedly told a joint news conference with the Polish foreign minister in Warsaw that Nord Stream-2 is a threat to Europe’s energy security.

Nevertheless, on January 31, the Stralsund Mining Authority issued the permit for the construction and operation in German territorial waters and the landfall area in Lubmin (near Greifswald), in accordance with the German Energy Industry Act.

“Today’s decision is an important milestone for European supply security and European consumers,” EU representative of Nord Stream-2 Sebastian Sass said in an email. “The construction and operation of Nord Stream-2 will take place in full compliance with applicable EU law, national legislation and international conventions,” Sass said, reminding that Nord Stream-2 said it submitted its permit applications and environmental impact assessments (EIA) materials to the relevant national authorities in the five “permitting countries” – Russia, Finland, Sweden, Denmark, and Germany – in compliance with the applicable national legislation.

Under the Espoo Convention, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland were also involved in this international consultation process, according to Nord Stream-2.

The European Commission has said that despite Nord Stream-2, Brussels wants gas transit via Ukraine to be maintained. Weafer he sees an “increase in dialogue between Europe and Russia over Ukraine”.

“Russia trying to engage more with Europe in the next couple of years to try and improve relations with Europe, as a counterbalance to kind of worsening position with the US and a key issue in those negotiations in engagement with Europe is, of course, Ukraine. So I would expect Russia making some concessions with regard to Ukraine specifically in order to try and improve relations with the European Union,” Weafer said.

He noted, however, that Russia is much more interested in Nord Stream-2 than it is in continued use of the Ukraine pipeline “but, nevertheless, I would think that Moscow would be perfectly willing to continue to supply gas to the Ukrainian pipeline in addition to Nord Stream-2, provided that the terms are right, if that improved its position with the European Union and, obviously, it would give some improved leverage with Kiev as well. It’s not an either or situation”.

follow on twitter @energyinsider

 

 

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Co-founder / Director of Energy & Climate Policy and Security at NE Global Media

Latest

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Don't miss

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Africa’s porous borders promote transnational crimes rather than deeper integration

For positive continental regimes to succeed, there must be both conscious and concerted efforts, as well as political will, from all states to help eliminate transnational crimes while fostering integration across the whole of Africa through trade.

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Kazakhstan’s new parliament could usher in green energy, rare earth investments

Kazakhstan held internationally monitored elections for the Mazhilis, the lower chamber of the Kazakh Parliament, on March 19, following major constitutional reforms, which most...

EU-Turkey earthquake relief conference: Time to get serious

The European Union is hosting a reconstruction conference in Brussels on March 20 to focus on the aftermath of Turkey’s devastating February 6 earthquakes,...

Energy supply diversification out of Russia’s orbit is a top priority for Bulgaria

Bulgaria intends to diversify its energy resources, including supplying the country’s main refinery in Burgas - the largest in the Balkans - with non-Russian...

Recovery from the disaster of the century needs more than a few months of international assistance

Two devastating earthquakes hit the Turkish-Syrian border on February 6. The epicenter of the first 7.7 magnitude quake struck 34 kilometers west of Gaziantep,...

Georgia has shown the world that a Kremlin project can be defeated

In early March, the world’s attention was on Georgia. We saw massive protests fueled by anger, concerns and fear, and eventually, we witnessed a...

Putin’s New START withdrawal has broad implications

Vladimir Putin continues to persuade Russians that the West provoked his imperialist war of aggression against Ukraine. His announcement that he would no longer...