Sunday, April 2, 2023
 
 

Malaysia shows how the private sector could lead on due diligence

- Advertisement -

If the rumors and press leaks are to be believed, the European Commission’s long-awaited proposal on Corporate Sustainable Governance is once again delayed. First expected in June, then December, and now … well, who knows. There are even suggestions – probably mischievous briefing rather than hard reality – that the proposal may be ditched altogether.

That possibility would uncork an intriguing debate across Europe. As the world’s largest single market, the EU has the ability to change behavior in exporting countries. Would the lack of strong Due Diligence regulations for labor rights, dent the EU’s moral authority around the world and set back the cause of global human rights? Or would it be a lucky escape for European businesses who would have suffered under the red tape of the new measures? 

Perhaps, the answer is both. The idea has supporters – and detractors – from across the political spectrum and within many Member State governments. Interestingly, these shifting coalitions are not always in their traditional corners. Many conservatives across Europe wish to see more regulation on labor issues, as a strong message to the Chinese Communist Party that the EU will no longer give a free pass to forced labor in supply chains in and around Xinjiang province. Many NGOs, Greens and civil society advocates favor the same restrictions, but with a stronger moral dimension as the motivation for so doing, rather than the geopolitical or security motivations favoured by many on the center-right.

The primary argument against the Commission’s planned measures is simple. The proposals are expected to add significant cost and bureaucratic burdens to European importers, by requiring due diligence to be conducted to ensure that all labor and human rights standards were adhered to throughout the supply chain. Pandemic-hit European businesses (and those taking an additional hit from growing global protectionism) need these new costs and red tape like they need a hole in the head.

As with many of the current Commission’s plans – the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism for instance – the plans would not only install new trade barriers at Europe’s border, they would encourage and validate the cause of global protectionism and economic nationalism more broadly. For a continent that relies on global trade, that could be a costly error of political judgment.

The von der Leyen Commission has been clear, though, that it is committed to these Due Diligence measures, both on environmental issues and on labor & human rights. The delay of the proposal is therefore doubly embarrassing as other countries move further and faster, and the Commission’s role as the self-appointed benevolent global regulator is weakened.

In the U.S., under both Trump and Biden Administrations, human and labor rights regulations have been considered a significant priority. The U.S. Customs & Border Patrol has the broad executive power to block imports if they are considered to be in breach of the U.S.’ labor and human rights standards. In recent years, products ranging from cotton to sheepskin, to rubber gloves, have been the subject of Withhold Released Orders that act as an ad hoc customs barrier for entering the U.S. market.

In exporting countries – who face seeing their products banned from the U.S. (and possibly, in future, the EU) market – self-regulation and reform is advancing at pace. The Malaysian Government has recently committed to ratifying key International Labor Organization (ILO) conventions, and the country’s palm oil association (MPOA) announced last week a new Responsible Employment Charter, committing companies to abide by standards of the ILO and the International Organization for Migration, as well as other international benchmarks.

What is fascinating about this development is the leadership of the country’s private sector -the MPOA is comprised only of private companies and GLCs, no officials or Ministers. The Charter commits to ending the practice of recruitment fees, for example, which are often an indicator of forced labor or human trafficking. Other industries, such as textiles, which also have significant exports to the U.S. and Europe, could learn from this approach rather than waiting for government regulation.

When, or whether, the Commission will publish its Sustainable Corporate Governance proposal remains to be seen. If so, the self-regulation and elevating standards that are emerging in other parts of the world, make a convincing case that the Commission does not need to be too aggressive with its regulations. It may even be an opportunity to learn from others – such as Malaysia’s private sector-led reforms.

Europe has a surfeit of business associations, roundtables, chambers, and other groups that could take the lead on developing private commitments, standards and charters that could match up with those being developed in exporting countries. The vibrancy and innovation of the market would almost certainly make a better tool for the needed reforms, much more so than the unwieldy clunking fist currently employed by the Commission.

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Latest

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Don't miss

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Africa’s porous borders promote transnational crimes rather than deeper integration

For positive continental regimes to succeed, there must be both conscious and concerted efforts, as well as political will, from all states to help eliminate transnational crimes while fostering integration across the whole of Africa through trade.

France’s policies in Africa diminish its influence; inevitably opening the door to Russia & China

In a recent story titled "How Russia and China are trying to drive France out of Africa", what was not lost on the reader...

Africa’s porous borders promote transnational crimes rather than deeper integration

For positive continental regimes to succeed, there must be both conscious and concerted efforts, as well as political will, from all states to help eliminate transnational crimes while fostering integration across the whole of Africa through trade.

A plea to strengthen the Single Market

Unprecedented geopolitical disturbances call for a more united European Union, not for more trade barriers that would ultimately harm the EU's economy and its citizens.

The Iranian regime is becoming ruthlessly paranoid about ethnic Azeri demands for civil rights guarantees

Complete disregard for the well-being of Iran’s Azeri minority has sparked a wave of intense anger within the community.

EU-Turkey earthquake relief conference: Time to get serious

The European Union is hosting a reconstruction conference in Brussels on March 20 to focus on the aftermath of Turkey’s devastating February 6 earthquakes,...

Cambodia’s current government is the face of tropical Fascism

There is no hope that the authoritarianism that the world sees in places like Russia, China and Cambodia can ever be interpreted as a peaceful and benign phenomenon, or that it should be accepted by an implicit racist or discriminatory assumption that some cultures just don’t have a democratic tradition and aren’t quite capable of ever developing one.

Georgia has shown the world that a Kremlin project can be defeated

In early March, the world’s attention was on Georgia. We saw massive protests fueled by anger, concerns and fear, and eventually, we witnessed a...

Putin’s New START withdrawal has broad implications

Vladimir Putin continues to persuade Russians that the West provoked his imperialist war of aggression against Ukraine. His announcement that he would no longer...