Thursday, July 18, 2024
 
 

Strange bedfellows: Iran sanctions, EU posturing and volatile oil markets

“If you wrote this in a novel nobody would believe you,” Urquhart Stewart tells New Europe

- Advertisement -

Oil prices remained near three and a half year highs on May 11 as the United States plans to reintroduce sanctions against Iran after the Administration of US President Donald J. Trump abandoned a landmark deal that sought to curb Iran’s nuclear program.

Iran pumps about 4% of the world’s oil. However, there is no shortage of oil, as the market remains balanced with Saudi Arabia and Russia having led efforts to curb oil supply to prop up prices. “I think you’re going to see some quite significant volatility in oil prices and that will be dependent upon what extent their confidence that the Iranian arrangement would be maintained and you could end up with some spikes occurring, but I suspect the Saudis will act to try to increase supply and to maintain the levels if at all possible,” Justin Urquhart Stewart, director at Seven Investment Management in London, told New Europe by phone on May 11. “But, of course, they are in contradiction here because the Americans have been increasing supply anyway and show no signs of wishing to weaken it at all, yet the Saudis still wish to maintain the price at a reasonable level. But anything that can put pain on the Iranians, the Saudis will do,” Urquhart Stewart added.

He said Saudi Arabia, Israel and the United States have become unusual allies, at least temporarily. “The Saudis and the Israelis and the Americans – if you wrote this in a novel nobody would believe you, but we find ourselves in this weird position that the European Union is stuck in the middle, Russia is an ally to Iran but is an unreliable ally and the Saudis and the Israelis are very unnatural bedfellows,” Urquhart Stewart said, adding that their suspicion at Iran runs very deep indeed.

He said Iran is unreliable ally to Russia but it’s in Russia’s interest to try and make sure that the price is sustained. “It’s in Russia’s interest if Iran did go along with Europe on some sort of maintenance of the agreement for the time being but frankly this could go either way and then, of course, the Europeans would have to make sure they stand firm against American actions against their own companies breaching any of the black-listing arrangements and that’s by no means certain,” Urquhart Stewart said.

France has condemned as “unacceptable” the US move to re-impose sanctions on all companies trading with Iran. BBC quoted French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian as saying European companies should not have to pay for the US decision. However, analysts question the effectiveness of any EU shielding legislation and point to the inevitability of a chill on all international transactions that would flow from US sanctions. At this point it’s just speculative.

Observers also wonder what impact the French-led EU initiative might have on ongoing US-EU negotiations on tariffs regarding steel and aluminum, the application of which the Trump Administration has temporarily suspended in regards to the European Union.

Basically, with this number of issues at play – energy markets, tariff policies, geopolitics and the legal complexity of US sanctions against Iran – quite some time will be required to frame the situation clearly.

“The EU is showing very little backbone in this politically, but I think is unlikely to take leadership and will make noises, but I suspect may well bend when some of its companies come under threat from America, let’s say Airbus orders to Iran and things like that,” Urquhart Stewart said. “Also, politically they’re not strongly united. They’ll make noises together but the actions, I suspect, will be very limited indeed,” he added.

follow on twitter @energyinsider

 

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Co-founder / Director of Energy & Climate Policy and Security at NE Global Media

Latest

Policies on Deforestation Show Europe’s Internal Splits

Former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger once famously...

NATO Summit: “Trump-proofing” Ukraine support while Biden appearances under a microscope

The July 9-11 NATO Summit was originally envisioned as...

Russia failing to replace lucrative European gas deliveries with sales to China

Russia’s attempts to build the Power of Siberia 2...

Astana SCO Summit reaffirms its growing geopolitical role

The 24th summit of the Council of Heads of...

Don't miss

Policies on Deforestation Show Europe’s Internal Splits

Former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger once famously...

NATO Summit: “Trump-proofing” Ukraine support while Biden appearances under a microscope

The July 9-11 NATO Summit was originally envisioned as...

Russia failing to replace lucrative European gas deliveries with sales to China

Russia’s attempts to build the Power of Siberia 2...

Astana SCO Summit reaffirms its growing geopolitical role

The 24th summit of the Council of Heads of...

Uzbekistan: A Key Player in the (Central Asian) Great Game

Uzbekistan has had considerable success in attracting billions of...

NATO Summit: “Trump-proofing” Ukraine support while Biden appearances under a microscope

The July 9-11 NATO Summit was originally envisioned as a celebration of the alliance’s 75th anniversary at the organization’s founding venue in Washington D.C.,...

Russia failing to replace lucrative European gas deliveries with sales to China

Russia’s attempts to build the Power of Siberia 2 (PS-2) natural gas pipeline to China appear to be stalling despite repeated statements from Moscow...

Uzbekistan: A Key Player in the (Central Asian) Great Game

Uzbekistan has had considerable success in attracting billions of dollars of aid, concessional debt, and co-investment, which has helped transform the economy since 2017....

EU strengthens energy cooperation with Chile, Argentina

This week EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson visited Chile and Argentina to step up cooperation with these two countries in the energy field, with...

Jeffrey Sachs: three times a traitor

An economist with an international reputation, Professor Jeffrey Sachs has increasingly raised his profile in the world media. A U.S. citizen, he accuses his...

Japan, the Republic of Korea (ROK), and the U.S. condemn DPRK-Russia Cooperation

During his June 19-20 visit to Pyongyang, Russian President Vladimir Putin and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un signed a comprehensive strategic partnership treaty...

European election results show EU is at an inflection point

A few days after the European Parliament elections, Marilena Raouna, Cyprus’ Deputy Minister for European Affairs, sat down with NE Global on the sidelines...

G7 Summit focuses on Ukraine support and shattering Russia’s wartime economy

Despite last week’s expert punditry (itself almost indistinguishable from AI) on the latest G7 decisions as exhibited by the “instant experts” on global issues...