Sunday, April 2, 2023
 
 

The EU’s risky green taxonomy

- Advertisement -

The European Union and the European Parliament are soon expected to adopt a so-called “taxonomy” for classifying green investments, after reaching agreement last month on a list of “sustainable” economic activities. Once the new system enters into force, most likely this year, the European Commission will use this list to determine which financial assets and products are sustainable.

This taxonomy is the backbone of the Commission’s regulatory package on sustainable finance, which has the ambitious goal of “reorient(ing) capital flows towards sustainable investment, in order to achieve sustainable and inclusive growth.” The Commission hopes that the new labeling scheme will address the problem of market players “greenwashing” non-sustainable financial products and serve as the basis for policy incentives to promote sustainable investment.

To be fit for purpose, however, the taxonomy must address three important questions. Unfortunately, the EU’s one-dimensional approach disregards two of the three, with potentially damaging consequences.

The Commission’s focus on the question of which economic activities are sustainable entails defining and listing all activities that contribute to the energy transition, such as generating renewable power or producing electric cars. The main debates have centered on the potential inclusion of nuclear power or natural gas, and whether to define “shades of green” rather than adopt a binary system.

But the EU taxonomy also should address a second big question: Which green activities face a financing gap? After all, from an environmental perspective, the sole purpose of reorienting financial flows toward such activities is to bridge a funding shortfall. And not all sustainable activities listed in the proposed taxonomy are necessarily underfinanced. In practice, the growth of certain green activities is capped by other factors, such as lack of consumer demand, an unfavorable tax environment, or technological obstacles. Indeed, a low level of financing may be a consequence of these difficulties rather than their cause.

Moreover, when a financing gap does exist, it does not necessarily apply to the entire spectrum of capital. Usually, the shortfall affects a specific phase, such as the so-called “valley of death” between venture capital and private equity.

In this context, channeling financing toward all activities defined as “sustainable,” including those that are not underfinanced, will not only dilute the effects of potential incentives (such as the “green supporting factor” envisioned by the Commission), but also risk creating an asset bubble. Yet, so far, the EU has simply ignored these potential problems.

Finally, the Commission has disregarded the evidence concerning the question of which financial instruments and products effectively influence the real economy.

One would expect European policymakers to encourage investments in instruments and products that help to scale up sustainable economic activities. For example, a recent review of academic research on the topic concluded that investors’ use of shareholder rights to support environmental resolutions is a “relatively reliable mechanism” for achieving such an outcome. And this approach is gaining traction, as illustrated by BlackRock’s recent decision to join the Climate Action 100+ coalition of investors pushing such resolutions. At the same time, however, the review noted that, “there is currently no empirical study that relates capital allocation decisions made by sustainable investors to corporate growth or to improvements in corporate practices.”

The Commission refers to this study, but has decided to act against the scientific evidence and base its sustainable-finance regulation on alternative facts. On one hand, the regulation identifies the exposure of portfolios to sustainable activities as the only way to deliver environmental outcomes. Or, as the Commission says, “Greenness is derived from the uses to which (financial products or investments) are being put in underlying assets or activities.” On the other hand, the regulatory package overlooks shareholder engagement as a means of shifting investment toward sustainable activities.

The EU’s one-dimensional approach heightens the risk of three especially harmful consequences. First, it increases the likelihood of mis-selling. Soon, the 40% of European retail investors who (according to our most recent survey, forthcoming in 2020) are concerned with the environmental impact of their savings could be systematically offered unsuitable products. Moreover, the regulation could impede competition by creating entry barriers for genuine environmental impact-investing strategies. Finally, by spurning evidence-based approaches in finance, the EU’s regulation could slow down the sector’s transition – thus hindering global efforts to tackle climate change.

As a member of the High-Level Expert Group that recommended the sustainable-finance action plan, I have repeatedly called the Commission’s attention to these issues and still struggle to make sense of the decisions made. But when it comes to addressing complex, multi-dimensional social issues with a simple one-dimensional solution, there is an interesting precedent.

Not so long ago, the United States government, together with the finance industry, tried to address a challenge simpler than climate change: boosting home ownership among low-income households. They chose to focus on subprime mortgages, combined with the magic bullet of securitisation. At some point, decision-makers thought that increasing market exposure to these subprime loans was a good proxy for helping low-income households to buy homes, and that no further assessment was necessary. We all know how that ended.

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Latest

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Don't miss

When it comes to defense, the politicians must listen to those who know best – the generals

The halls of power are walked by people who know little, care even less and yet have the right to supersede and ignore the advice of those who know better.

Silicon Valley Bank financial contagion contained – for now

The world’s top policymakers and international financial leaders acted effectively in the days following the collapse of California’s Silicon Valley Bank. They appear to have dealt positively with the risk of wider global financial contagion.

EU plan to centralize gas purchases near impossible to implement

The global gas supply market will be much tighter this year than it was in 2022. The need for the EU to buy more gas, especially more liquified natural gas, from elsewhere will be greater.

Africa’s porous borders promote transnational crimes rather than deeper integration

For positive continental regimes to succeed, there must be both conscious and concerted efforts, as well as political will, from all states to help eliminate transnational crimes while fostering integration across the whole of Africa through trade.

France’s policies in Africa diminish its influence; inevitably opening the door to Russia & China

In a recent story titled "How Russia and China are trying to drive France out of Africa", what was not lost on the reader...

Africa’s porous borders promote transnational crimes rather than deeper integration

For positive continental regimes to succeed, there must be both conscious and concerted efforts, as well as political will, from all states to help eliminate transnational crimes while fostering integration across the whole of Africa through trade.

A plea to strengthen the Single Market

Unprecedented geopolitical disturbances call for a more united European Union, not for more trade barriers that would ultimately harm the EU's economy and its citizens.

The Iranian regime is becoming ruthlessly paranoid about ethnic Azeri demands for civil rights guarantees

Complete disregard for the well-being of Iran’s Azeri minority has sparked a wave of intense anger within the community.

Cambodia’s current government is the face of tropical Fascism

There is no hope that the authoritarianism that the world sees in places like Russia, China and Cambodia can ever be interpreted as a peaceful and benign phenomenon, or that it should be accepted by an implicit racist or discriminatory assumption that some cultures just don’t have a democratic tradition and aren’t quite capable of ever developing one.

Georgia has shown the world that a Kremlin project can be defeated

In early March, the world’s attention was on Georgia. We saw massive protests fueled by anger, concerns and fear, and eventually, we witnessed a...

Putin’s New START withdrawal has broad implications

Vladimir Putin continues to persuade Russians that the West provoked his imperialist war of aggression against Ukraine. His announcement that he would no longer...

Free Trade: The magic potion against economic decline

Despite rising internal and external nationalistic pressure, leaders on both sides of the Atlantic should remember that in a time of increasing hostilities from bad actors, retaliatory protectionism toward our allies will do nothing but ensure mutual decline.