Wednesday, February 21, 2024
 
 

The wait is over. Name Dispute agreement comes together

Two embattled leaders deliver Name Dispute agreement

- Advertisement -

After a delayed set of phone calls June 11 and 12, and a late June 12 intervention by UN Mediator Matthew Nimetz, the prime ministers of Greece and Macedonia/FYROM apparently reached an agreement on Macedonia/FYROM’s new official name – “The Republic of Northern Macedonia.”
Official announcements in both countries are forthcoming. A meeting at Prespes on the border of both countries has been set for June 16 for a formal signature on the twenty-page agreement. As expected, early reactions in both countries are negative to a gambit which could improve the chances of political survival for both embattled leaders or in extreme scenarios, accelerate the departure of at least one of the negotiating partners.
Sequencing is key
The new agreed name will be “The Republic of Northern Macedonia,” in Slavic the “Republika Severna Makedonija.” The agreement has not been released for public scrutiny, causing great concern in both countries. It is not yet known what percentage of the “deliverables” (changes) which Greece expects from Macedonia/FYROM will be accepted on some form of delayed schedule later this year and what are Athens specific commitments regarding Skopje’s EU and NATO applications. Observers in Greece, a country for years forced to live under the tight foreign supervision of its economy, find it ironic that Greece is now the overseer in this deal.
Great giveaway or strategic victory? Time for reinvention in Skopje

If the deal is actualized it will close a conflict that has existed since Macedonia/FYROM declared independence in 1991, or much earlier, depending on how you interpret history. Achieving the Greek side’s unflinching demand for a single hybrid name for all purposes, using the now-familiar Latin term “Erga Omnes” is the great strategic victory for Athens, as this essentially forces Macedonia/FYROM to totally reinvent itself, and not simply for “international contacts,” as earlier rounds of negotiations had intended.
This will require constitutional changes by Skopje as will the removal of irredentist references from the document, which can be promised by Prime Minister Zoran Zaev but not guaranteed until after a referendum is held, as well as other important steps taken. Numerous observers in Skopje and abroad directly question Zaev’s ability to deliver. Another concern is how the draft agreement treats the so-called “Macedonian” nationality, an explosive issue for a large majority in Greece.
Reactions in Greece
So, the leaders have agreed. The question in the Greek political calculus is whether the deal is enough to rupture either of two fragile political fissures at a time when poll-trailing Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras is also working to pass painful new economic reform legislation through his parliament before Greece exits its international bailout regime in August.
For now, Tsipras’ coalition with the right-wing Independent Greeks (ANEL) party is limping forward, although Defense Minister and ANEL Leader Panos Kammenos resolutely maintains his party’s deputies will not vote in support of the agreement, making passage in Greece an open question. He also believes strongly that the Macedonian/FYROM side will not be able to produce the promised constitutional changes or a successful referendum. Accordingly, he has argued much of the upcoming debate on the deal in Greece will be based on incorrect assumptions.
The second fault line exposed by the Name Dispute deal lies within the main opposition party New Democracy which is widely favoured to win the next elections. Party leader Kyriakos Mitsotakis must walk a fine line here, as his party’s right wing will have problems accepting any use of a compound name; in any event he will not give SYRIZA the parliamentary support it needs for passage and is already taking steps to challenge the “legitimacy” of the Tsipras government’s secret negotiating record. Late on June 12 Mitsotakis noted he had asked Tsipras not to sign this “bad agreement.” He called the acceptance of a Macedonian language and ethnicity “unacceptable national concessions,” adding “we will not divide Greeks to unite the Skopjans.”
The ruling SYRIZA party nonetheless hopes to weaken New Democracy by pressing Mitsotakis to take a moderate approach in the parliamentary debate on the deal, whenever that happens. There is some speculation that a vote on the agreement on the Greek side could be months off.
Reactions in Macedonia/FYROM
In Skopje the question remains whether Prime Minister Zaev can deliver the votes needed, when needed, to move ahead with constitutional revisions.
President Gjorge Ivanov, originally from the opposition VMRO-DPMNE party, has not publicly reversed his on-the-record opposition to constitutional changes. Without these, the deal falls apart.
Foreign intervention – was it the key?

While many in Greece will believe that PM Tsipras got his marching orders on the Name Dispute while visiting President Donald J. Trump at the White House in October 2017, the visible interference from American officials has been refreshingly low and nuanced. In fact, leading media commentators rate Berlin, Brussels, and Washington as key the foreign influencers on the deal, in that order, but tend to focus excessively on lack of visible US pressure while obsessing over each and every statement made by German officials.
The lack of strong interest by several key EU countries in immediate EU expansion is frequently cited in Athens as a reason to partially disregard the June 28-29 EU Council meeting as a real target date for the deal, yet it currently appears that target could well be met.

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

CEO / co-founder and Executive Director for Global Economics and Southeast Europe at NE Global Media.  Former US diplomat with previous assignments in Eastern Europe, the UN, SE Asia, Greece, across the Balkans, as well as Washington DC.

Latest

Romania sees Black Sea renewable hub, gas production growth

Ambitious projects and cross-border cooperation between the countries in...

Qatar, Kazakhstan to boost economic ties, energy projects

Qatar and Kazakhstan discussed economic cooperation between the two...

Bulgaria, Romania push regional renewable energy projects

Bulgaria is working with its neighbors to boost energy...

Kremlin disinformation efforts in Africa illuminated

The U.S. State Department released a report detailing Kremlin...

Don't miss

Romania sees Black Sea renewable hub, gas production growth

Ambitious projects and cross-border cooperation between the countries in...

Qatar, Kazakhstan to boost economic ties, energy projects

Qatar and Kazakhstan discussed economic cooperation between the two...

Bulgaria, Romania push regional renewable energy projects

Bulgaria is working with its neighbors to boost energy...

Kremlin disinformation efforts in Africa illuminated

The U.S. State Department released a report detailing Kremlin...

EU law banning greenwashing to empower consumers for the green transition

Companies can no longer market their goods using unfounded...

Investors Forum brings the Middle Corridor into EU-wide focus

Huge investment numbers were thrown around in Brussels January 29-30 at the Global Gateway Investors Forum for the European Union – Central Asia Transport...

UNRWA blasted for allegations that staffers supported Hamas

The United Nations agency that manages support for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, said on January 26 that it is starting an investigation into several employees...

Canada and aiding the democratic cause in Ukraine

Though the funding of Ukraine’s war against Russia remains the main topic of the American Congress, Ukraine’s relationship with its other key Western partners,...

US designates Yemen’s Houthis as terrorist organization

The Biden administration announced on January 17 that it is re-designating the Houthis, an Iranian-backed, Yemeni Shia Islamist group, as a terrorist organization. The...

Myanmar’s instability deepens as the world watches silently

Myanmar’s stability has eroded significantly since the 2021 military coup. But the coordinated attacks by multiple separatist and pro-democracy groups in late 2023 has...

Joint Statement on the Trilateral United States-Japan-Republic of Korea Indo-Pacific Dialogue

The inaugural Trilateral Indo-Pacific Dialogue between the United States Japan and South Korea was held on January 5, with this new format presented as...

Viking Link undersea cable to power up UK and Denmark

On December 29, Danish transmission system operator (TSO) Energinet launched the Viking Link, the world’s longest electricity interconnector, establishing a subsea cable connection across...

For Turkey, the Kurds are always considered terrorists

“Hamas is a reality for Palestine. It is a political party … it entered the elections as a political party and won,” said Turkey’s...