Saturday, April 13, 2024
 
 

Merkel, Putin to discuss Nord Stream-2 and Ukraine transit

If Merkel and Putin effectively give a political green light to Nord Stream-2 at the Meseberg palace, Denmark may eventually grant a permit, possibly even in respect of the southern route, Yafimava tells NE.

- Advertisement -

When German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Russian President Vladimir Putin meet at the Meseberg Palace outside Berlin on August 18, the two leaders will reportedly discuss the Nord Stream-2 gas pipeline, which plans to transport Russian gas to Germany as well as Merkel’s demand that some gas transit via Ukraine is preserved.

“I would expect that the Merkel-Putin meeting at Messeberg could result in a broad declaration, which would re-emphasize all the points already made in respect of Nord Stream-2, that Nord Stream-2 proceeds as is under applicable laws provided that some transit across Ukraine is preserved,” Katja Yafimava, a senior research fellow at the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, told New Europe on August 15, explaining that transit across Ukraine could then be addressed separately in the process of trilateral EU-Russia-Ukraine talks, the first round which has recently been held in Berlin, mediated by European Commission Vice President for Energy Union Maroš Šefčovič.

“The fact that the Merkel-Putin meeting is due to take place at Messeberg where the German-French declaration on re-invigorating and strengthening the EU was signed just a few months ago – which inter alia includes provisions on ‘looking into new ways of increasing the speed and effectiveness of the EU’s decision making’ in its common foreign and security policy – is symbolic as it suggests that whatever is agreed during the meeting will be done in the spirit of the Messeberg declaration and is therefore done as a matter of common EU interest,” Yafimava said. “Should this be the case, and should the Merkel-Putin meeting effectively give a political green light to Nord Stream-2, I would not be surprised if Nord Stream-2 would start pipe laying offshore shortly afterwards,” the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies expert added.

All Russian permits for NS-2 received

On August 14, the developer for pipeline announced that Nord Stream-2 received a permit for the installation of an underwater pipeline in Russia’s territorial waters. The permit has been issued by Russia’s Federal Agency for the Supervision of Natural Resources Use (Rosprirodnadzor) in accordance with the established procedure. The permit covers a section of approximately 114 kilometres inside Russia’s territorial sea. The Russian  Ministry of Construction and Utilities had previously issued a construction permit for Nord Stream-2 within Russia’s borders. All the permits necessary for construction of the Russian section of the Nord Stream-2 Pipeline have now been received.

“There was no serious doubt that the Russian permit would be granted, so this was not really a hurdle,” Yafimava told New Europe.

Danish hurdle

In addition to Russia, Germany, Finland and Sweden have granted all the permits necessary for construction of the planned pipeline within their jurisdictions. The national permitting procedure in Denmark is ongoing.

“The absence of the Danish permit is indeed a hurdle – NS2 has recently submitted another application to the Danish authority in respect of the alternative route (north of Bronholm) while the previous application in respect of the original route (south of Bronholm) is also pending – this hurdle still needs to be overcome,” Yafimava said.

She explained that while Denmark would be able to reject the southern route on the basis of its new law allowing not to allow construction of pipelines in its territorial waters, which would be the case with the southern route, on foreign policy and security grounds – should it decide to do so, which it has not done to date – the Danish energy agency would not be able to reject the northern route on any grounds other than environmental – and this would be next to impossible to justify – as it would only pass through the Danish Exclusive Economic Zone but not territorial waters.

“It is understood that the southern route is better than the northern route from the environmental point of view. Denmark has notably stated on several occasions that it does not want to take a decision on Nord Stream-2 alone on its own, arguing that it is an EU-wide issue – which explains why it has not made any decision yet,” Yafimava said.

She noted, however, that if Merkel and Putin effectively gave a political green light to Nord Stream-2, “I would also not be surprised if Denmark were to eventually grant a permit, possibly even in respect of the southern route, which is better from the environmental point of view”.

WTO panel report on EU-Russia dispute

Yafimava said it is also noteworthy that the recent World Trade Organization (WTO) panel report on the dispute between Russia and the European Union in respect of Third Energy Package compatibility with the WTO law while positive for the EU on the majority of issues, is also positive for Russia in respect of treatment of Nord Stream-1 onshore extension (Germany’s OPAL pipeline) while also making it very difficult for the EU to discriminate against Nord Stream-2 onshore extension (EUGAL) in the future.

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Co-founder / Director of Energy & Climate Policy and Security at NE Global Media

Latest

Western corporations must be held accountable for their role in China’s Uyghur genocide

In recent testimony before the Senate, U.S. Treasury Secretary...

New U.S.-Japan-Philippines Pacific bulwark established

The leaders of Japan, the Philippines, and the United...

The influence of Russia’s nuclear industry steadily expanding in Turkey

Turkey's decision last month that Russian State Atomic Energy...

Don't miss

Western corporations must be held accountable for their role in China’s Uyghur genocide

In recent testimony before the Senate, U.S. Treasury Secretary...

New U.S.-Japan-Philippines Pacific bulwark established

The leaders of Japan, the Philippines, and the United...

The influence of Russia’s nuclear industry steadily expanding in Turkey

Turkey's decision last month that Russian State Atomic Energy...

Kyrgyz “Foreign Representatives Law” enacted amid criticism

On April 2, Kyrgyz President Sadyr Japarov announced that...

EU, U.S., Uzbekistan and other partners strengthen critical raw materials cooperation

The European Union, the United States, and other Minerals Security Partnership (MSP) partners, joined by Kazakhstan, Namibia, Ukraine, and Uzbekistan, officially launched the Minerals...

The influence of Russia’s nuclear industry steadily expanding in Turkey

Turkey's decision last month that Russian State Atomic Energy Corporation Rosatom will build the country’s second nuclear power plant, most likely at a site...

Pro-nuclear leaders push atomic energy to cut CO2 emissions, boost security of supply

A global push to expand nuclear power continued recently as world leaders from more than 30 countries and the European Union met at the...

Can Innovation Diplomacy End the Climate Gamble?

With today’s global challenges urging equally global responses, an overlooked subset of diplomacy emerges as potentially pivotal: innovation diplomacy, a discipline related to the...

U.S. joins International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children

On March 7, the office of the spokesperson at the U.S. Department of State issued a media note, clearly meant to be circulated in...

Eyeing competitors, OPEC+ countries will keep cutting oil production

Several OPEC+ countries are extending additional voluntary cuts of 2.2 million barrels per day, aimed at supporting what they are labeling "the stability and...

EU Parliament strives to protect energy market from manipulation

Responding to the energy crisis exacerbated by Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the European Parliament approved on February 29 legislation to tackle energy market manipulation...

Russia sanctions remain a powerful tool to support Ukraine’s defense

Western leaders should not dismiss the two-year long sanctions campaign (as opposed to the 2014 Crimea sanctions) as unsuccessful simply because the Kremlin has...