Thursday, March 28, 2024
 
 

Lower Oil Prices Won’t Upset Slick Putin

- Advertisement -

Claims that $80 oil would lead to an economic crisis in Russia and an end to the presidency of Vladimir Putin are not true, Chris Weafer, a senior partner with consultancy Macro-Advisory in Moscow, wrote in an e-mailed note to investors on 14 February.

“One of the frequently heard criticisms about Russia is that the economy and socio-political stability are completely dependent on the price of oil,” Weafer wrote. “In recent weeks, in the run up to the Olympics, there have been several articles published claiming that at an average of $80 per barrel for Urals crude, economic growth would collapse and lead to social instability which would, in turn, bring about radical political change and an end to the Putin presidency. It would not. The short answer is that oil averaging down to $80, possibly to $70, per barrel would do neither,” the Moscow-based expert wrote.

But Julian Lee, senior energy analyst at London’s Centre for Global Energy Studies (CGES), told New Europe on 14 February that an $80-per-barrel oil price, were it to persist for any length of time, will undoubtedly cause real difficulties for the Russian economy. The country is heavily reliant on tax revenues from the oil and gas sector to fund expenditure. Russia needs an oil price of at least $100 per barrel to fund planned spending from current income, without drawing on reserves. “Like many big oil and gas-dependent countries, it could weather a short period of lower prices, but it is unable to boost production to offset such a fall and economic problems would quickly begin to emerge,” Lee said.

Weafer wrote that the Russian ruble will partly compensate for lower oil. “If the price of Urals were to slide sharply the ruble would also be allowed to weaken against the dollar to protect budget ruble revenue. We saw this in 2012 when Urals fell quickly from $120 per barrel to $90 per barrel. We should get the same response again in the event of an oil price slide,” Weafer wrote, adding that the weak ruble is already helping. 

He noted that an oil price drop would increase the budget deficit and the domestic and foreign public debt. Moreover, the lower ruble rate would add to inflationary pressures.

But, lower oil would also bring some benefits, including increasing pressure to restructure budget spending so as to cut or reschedule less productive spending in favour of spending which might boost economic activity. The privatization programme would likely pick up again. Moreover, there would be more support for plans to reform the pensions system and to regulate the insurance market so as to help build a bigger pool of domestic long term capital, Weafer wrote. Furthermore, lower oil would reduce the current complacency within government and help accelerate efforts to improve the investment and business climate, he wrote.

Turning to politics, Weafer noted that there is no evidence of a loss of support for Putin. Lower oil, if only down to $80 or even $70 per barrel, would not materially change the political landscape. Suggestions that public support for Putin is falling are also not supported with the evidence, Weafer wrote, pointing out that Saudi Arabia would be in more trouble than Russia and sooner.

follow on twitter @energyinsider

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Co-founder / Director of Energy & Climate Policy and Security at NE Global Media

Latest

U.S. condemns latest PRC actions in South China Sea as dangerous

Coming just days after U.S. Secretary of State Antony...

With Sweden now a NATO member, what’s next?

Sweden completed the necessary diplomatic formalities on March 7,...

Inaugural B5+1 Forum launched to boost regional trade and investment

On March 13-15, government policymakers, business leaders, experts, and...

U.S. zeroes in on Houthi revenue sources

The U.S. Government made several announcements this month regarding...

Don't miss

U.S. condemns latest PRC actions in South China Sea as dangerous

Coming just days after U.S. Secretary of State Antony...

With Sweden now a NATO member, what’s next?

Sweden completed the necessary diplomatic formalities on March 7,...

Inaugural B5+1 Forum launched to boost regional trade and investment

On March 13-15, government policymakers, business leaders, experts, and...

U.S. zeroes in on Houthi revenue sources

The U.S. Government made several announcements this month regarding...

EU adopts safeguards on general purpose artificial intelligence

The European Parliament took an important step in regulating...

Can Innovation Diplomacy End the Climate Gamble?

With today’s global challenges urging equally global responses, an overlooked subset of diplomacy emerges as potentially pivotal: innovation diplomacy, a discipline related to the...

Eyeing competitors, OPEC+ countries will keep cutting oil production

Several OPEC+ countries are extending additional voluntary cuts of 2.2 million barrels per day, aimed at supporting what they are labeling "the stability and...

EU Parliament strives to protect energy market from manipulation

Responding to the energy crisis exacerbated by Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the European Parliament approved on February 29 legislation to tackle energy market manipulation...

Chosen to host COP29, Azerbaijan draws special attention to its energy policy

Azerbaijan’s Energy Minister Parviz Shahbazov visited the U.S. this week where he held talks with World Bank representatives, U.S. government officials and investors, discussing...

Romania sees Black Sea renewable hub, gas production growth

Ambitious projects and cross-border cooperation between the countries in the region are key in order for the Black Sea to become a renewables energy...

Qatar, Kazakhstan to boost economic ties, energy projects

Qatar and Kazakhstan discussed economic cooperation between the two countries, including energy and signed a number of commercial agreements totaling almost USD 18 billion...

Bulgaria, Romania push regional renewable energy projects

Bulgaria is working with its neighbors to boost energy security and collaborate on joint cross-border projects in natural gas and renewables, according to Bulgaria’s...

Record-high American LNG exports reinforce EU energy security drive

US liquefied natural gas, or LNG, exports reportedly hit monthly and annual record highs in December, positioning the United States to potentially become the...