Monday, December 4, 2023
 
 

Could there be dark days ahead for buyers of solar panels?

- Advertisement -

A landmark ruling is casting a shadow over Europe’s booming solar industry with manufacturers and buyers of solar panels facing a potential stand-off over recycling costs. 

Following legal action brought by a Czech company, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) partly placed the financial burden of disposing of old solar panels onto buyers – a decision that could have far-reaching implications for the rest of Europe, according to senior lawyers.

Perez-Llorca, a leading law firm in Spain, is now recommending operators check their contracts with solar panel manufacturers regarding shipments made to the EU between August 13, 2005, and August 13, 2012.

Juan Rodriquez Carcamo, a partner in the law firm and specialist in EU law, said that the ruling made in January 2022 by the ECJ partially invalidates a previous directive on waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE Directive), which had placed the financial burden of the disposal of solar panels on the manufacturer.

In its ruling, the European court said that because the 27 members of the EU previously had the freedom to place the obligation of paying on either the manufacturer or the user of solar panels before 2012, the WEEE directive could not be applied retroactively.

This means that in the absence of any clear guidelines on the issue from the EU in the months since, manufacturers of solar panels sold in Europe between 2005-2012 could potentially challenge the obligation to take on recycling costs, putting the financial burden on operators.

“So far, the judgement of the ECJ appears not to have been tested in Europe, but it is only a matter of time before a producer defends their right and uses this judgement,” Mr Carcamo warned.

“These panels have a long, useful life of around 15 years, so in 2022, we are seeing panels that entered the market in 2007 coming to the end of their life and so this obligation on producers to take back and recycle the panels they sold is potentially costly.”

While the ECJ ruling currently applies to legal action brought by a Czech company that claimed Czech authorities had wrongly transposed the EU directive into domestic law, Mr Carcamo, said the decision is likely to affect other members of the bloc.

He further claimed that some major manufacturers were already considering counterclaims, arguing that the EU’s 2012 rule change rendered them unable to foresee, at the time they designed the panels, that they would be required to finance recycling costs.

Brussels-based Sonsoles Centeno, who is also with law firm Perez-Llorca, added: “Since 2012 the rules have been clear, but in respect of panels that entered the market between 2005-2012, the question arises over who is responsible for waste management.

“In some cases, the user can check their agreement and see who is responsible. In my view, contracts during that period should be reviewed by both parties. The ECJ ruling opens the door for producers to argue it is not their responsibility.”

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Latest

US-Central Asia relations: It’s time for a Green 5+1

During the United Nations General Assembly in September, a...

Ukraine, Middle East will dominate Cameron’s UK foreign policy agenda

David Cameron, who was made Foreign Secretary in a...

What will it take to prevent a Gaza reconstruction fiasco?

Let us be unequivocal about the current war between...

Don't miss

US-Central Asia relations: It’s time for a Green 5+1

During the United Nations General Assembly in September, a...

Ukraine, Middle East will dominate Cameron’s UK foreign policy agenda

David Cameron, who was made Foreign Secretary in a...

What will it take to prevent a Gaza reconstruction fiasco?

Let us be unequivocal about the current war between...

Ukraine’s persecuted mayor

Lest it be forgotten, the major thematic issue in...

US-Central Asia relations: It’s time for a Green 5+1

During the United Nations General Assembly in September, a historic meeting took place: President Joe Biden met with the presidents of the five nations...

Russia’s powerful economic levers over Armenia

Armenia's relations with its strategic partner Russia are getting worse and worse and its leaders seem to desire a shift in geopolitical orientation towards the West....

Economy Minister says Kazakhstan to expand investment and diversify trade with Europe

Kazakhstan’s Minister of National Economy, Alibek Kuantyrov, spoke to NE Global in an exclusive interview about his country's relations with Europe, Astana's economic partners,...

Rebuilding Ukraine: Opportunities and concerns for foreign businesses

Such is the scale of the effort required to rebuild Ukraine that the World Bank in March 2023 estimated it at $411 billion. That...

Why China’s new map has stirred regional tensions

In the waning days of summer, closely following a BRICS summit and mere days ahead of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and Group...

New DFC commitments to maritime infrastructure projects

The US recently announced two major commitments to funding maritime infrastructure and related commercial projects, one in Sri Lanka and another in Greece through...

The EU Green Deal is a barrier to trade and global partnerships

There is an English saying that if you can’t see the wood for the trees, then you should step back and then you will...

IEA warns transitions bring new risks to energy security

Clean technology and critical mineral supply chains are highly geographically concentrated, the International Energy Agency warned in its World Energy Outlook for 2023 and...