Thursday, March 28, 2024
 
 

Legal case over melee during Erdogan’s 2017 DC visit moving ahead

- Advertisement -

Legal proceedings against Turkish security officers continue to move forward in Washington DC, based on actions they were seen taking against protestors in video recordings during the May 2017 visit to Washington of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.  

A melee broke out after a small group of anti-Erdogan demonstrators gathered near the Turkish ambassador’s central Washington residence after Erdogan met with President Donald Trump at the White House on May 16, 2017.  Among the anti-Erdogan protestors were Kurdish and Armenian community representatives. 

Security team’s reactions went beyond basic protective duties

The harsh reaction of Erdogan’s security team to the protest, injuring at least 11, some seriously, was considered unacceptably violent and charges were quickly filed by the Washington, DC police, launching a series of legal battles that continue to irritate US-Turkish relations, since the concept of sovereign immunity has been invoked to protect the Turkish officers involved.  The initial American legal volley included indictments against 15 Turkish security personnel, as well as two American citizens of Turkish ancestry and two Canadian citizens, all of whom are supporters of Erdogan.  The two Turkish-Americans involved in the melee pled guilty to felony assault charges and served prison sentences. 

At the time, then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson’s State Department angrily summoned the Turkish ambassador for an explanation as to why Erdogan’s security guards crossed the DC police lines to attack protestors.  Reactions from Capitol Hill were more intense, as U.S. Senators John McCain and Dianne Feinstein sent a terse letter to the Turkish government, demanding it take responsibility for a clash; at the time McCain also told a television interview he believed the Turkish ambassador should be expelled as a result of the melee.

 Lack of evidence or instructions from above?

Eventually, US prosecutors quietly dropped charges against 11 of the 15 indicted members of Turkish President Erdogan’s security detail, reportedly for lack of evidence. Turkey actually claimed some of the named officers were not in Washington when the melee occurred.  

Some analysts argue that these instructions came from Trump himself and see parallels with White House pressure for a go-slow approach on the Turkish Halkbank case in New York in order to satisfy Erdogan’s repeated demands, a matter discussed in some detail by former National Security Adviser John Bolton in his latest book. 

The indictment against seven of the security guards was withdrawn in February 2018, a day before outgoing Secretary of State Rex Tillerson visited Turkey to meet with Erdogan in a failed attempt to rebuild frayed bilateral relations.

Current developments unfavorable for Turkey

Fast forward to 2021. Primary legal action is now focused on civil claims. The case is coming up for review in a federal appeals court, which will review the government of Turkey’s appeal of a 2020 decision it lost. The court heard preliminary oral arguments in January. In February 2020, a federal judge found that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) did not protect those carrying out assaults on a peaceful protest on U.S. soil, as was the case with Erdogan’s guards in 2017.  

In January, the three-judge panel handling the case solicited the incoming Biden administration’s views on the case and asked for input by early March.  In addition, Democrats and Republicans sent a bipartisan letter from the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and House Committee on Foreign Affairs urging Secretary of State Blinken to support the protesters’ case against the government of Turkey. 

A Washington Metropolitan Police poster showing the faces of four Turkish security officials suspected of provoking clashes at the Turkish Ambassador’s Residence in Washington, D.C. on May 16, 2017. SOURCE: YOUTUBE/VOA

The letter’s signatories are Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), Sen. James E. Risch (R-Idaho), Rep. Gregory W. Meeks (D-N.Y.), and Rep. Michael T. McCaul (R-Texas). The letter’s key point was explicit  “We urge you to make clear the principle that foreign security personnel should not enjoy immunity under the FSIA for engaging in unprovoked assaults on peaceful protestors lawfully exercising their First Amendment rights in the United States.” 

Andreas Akaras, a Washington-based attorney for the anti-Erdogan protesters, told New Europe “Correspondence from the House’s and Senate’s foreign relations committees to Secretary Blinken demonstrate that not only the Biden administration but also the Congress share this view; therefore, all branches of government have demonstrated their desire for accountability for Turkish unlawful action.” 

The Biden administration’s brief, produced by senior attorneys within the Justice and State Departments in consultation with other experts and released this week, was unequivocal: The lower court’s ruling should be upheld, and the FSIA’s shield of immunity only extends so far. “The actions the Turkish agents took after the initial attack leave little doubt that they were using force for a purpose outside their proper protective function,” the brief states.

Attorney Akaras was upbeat in describing for New Europe the Biden administration’s position as laid out in the newly released amicus curiae (friend of the court) brief.  He noted “The submission by the administration makes clear that Turkey’s actions were beyond any sense of reasonableness and were intentionally aimed at visiting violence upon the protestors.”

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Latest

U.S. condemns latest PRC actions in South China Sea as dangerous

Coming just days after U.S. Secretary of State Antony...

With Sweden now a NATO member, what’s next?

Sweden completed the necessary diplomatic formalities on March 7,...

Inaugural B5+1 Forum launched to boost regional trade and investment

On March 13-15, government policymakers, business leaders, experts, and...

U.S. zeroes in on Houthi revenue sources

The U.S. Government made several announcements this month regarding...

Don't miss

U.S. condemns latest PRC actions in South China Sea as dangerous

Coming just days after U.S. Secretary of State Antony...

With Sweden now a NATO member, what’s next?

Sweden completed the necessary diplomatic formalities on March 7,...

Inaugural B5+1 Forum launched to boost regional trade and investment

On March 13-15, government policymakers, business leaders, experts, and...

U.S. zeroes in on Houthi revenue sources

The U.S. Government made several announcements this month regarding...

EU adopts safeguards on general purpose artificial intelligence

The European Parliament took an important step in regulating...

U.S. condemns latest PRC actions in South China Sea as dangerous

Coming just days after U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited Manila (March 19), Washington released on March 23 a strongly worded statement of...

With Sweden now a NATO member, what’s next?

Sweden completed the necessary diplomatic formalities on March 7, depositing its instrument of accession with the U.S. State Department in Washington, which manages the...

Inaugural B5+1 Forum launched to boost regional trade and investment

On March 13-15, government policymakers, business leaders, experts, and investors from C5+1 countries inaugurated the first-ever Business 5+1 (B5+1) Forum which was held in...

U.S. zeroes in on Houthi revenue sources

The U.S. Government made several announcements this month regarding new sanctions on Houthi revenue sources, building on steps taken in coordination with the U.K....

EU adopts safeguards on general purpose artificial intelligence

The European Parliament took an important step in regulating technology, approving on March 13 the EU's proposed Artificial Intelligence Act that aims to ensure...

U.S. joins International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children

On March 7, the office of the spokesperson at the U.S. Department of State issued a media note, clearly meant to be circulated in...

Eyeing competitors, OPEC+ countries will keep cutting oil production

Several OPEC+ countries are extending additional voluntary cuts of 2.2 million barrels per day, aimed at supporting what they are labeling "the stability and...

Intellexa Commercial Spyware Consortium sanctioned

The U.S. Government announced on March 5 a new set of sanctions on the members of the Intellexa Commercial Spyware Consortium based across Europe....