Friday, July 12, 2024
 
 

What happens when due diligence cannot or will not be applied?

WIKIPEDIA
A general view of the building housing Slovakia's National Cuncil.

- Advertisement -

When due diligence and a basic compliance process is not followed bad things happen. On October 21, 2021, an investigative journalist centre published a story that quickly became a national scandal in Slovakia. Some 28 companies were allegedly paid almost €24 million as part of the government scheme to help businesses cope with the effects of the pandemic, these companies are shell companies with no activities, employees or tax returns. So what went wrong? 

These companies turned out to be the very worst examples of what a shell company is. Registerd in Slovakia, with owners abroad (mainly from Croatia or Greece), with virtual P.O. Box addresses in Slovakia, no contact details, no employees, no health or social insurance contributions and tax returns that were not filed in years. At the time when the story broke much was said about the political responsibilities of a particular minister and the slow communication of the ministry of labour social affair and family of the Slovak republic. 

At the beginning of the pandemic, as elsewhere in Europe, aid to businesses could be slow and cumbersome, fears of abuse were greater than the will to expedite help quickly. However, over a relatively short time, the process became clearer, more manageable and slightly more user friendly. As both business and labor office staff adjusted to the new reality. 

The crucial document when applying for state assistance was a signed affidavit by the company’s owner stating the number of employees on furlough and lost profit are true at the time of applying for state’s assistance. Upon which assistance could start. The state made a choice, it divested the power of trust when accepting these applications to the officers at every application desk in every district labor office. Rather than burdening the companies applying for help with the need for providing evidence and carrying out due diligence upfront the government made a choice. Local knowledge of officials will ensure the timely payout for assistance. The choice was also made to ensure meticulous after-the-fact checks. 

In short, the state will not try to prevent potential abuse, but it will avenge it.  The big weak spot of this approach was an assumption that the small-time swindlers claiming to have 6 instead of 5 employees will remain in-country and it will always be possible to recover the money from businesses later, even years later. 

These shell companies with foreign owners in collusion with what appears to be an insider at one particular labor office have ensured that it will take a lot of effort and taxpayers money to investigate and recover even a fraction of the allegedly paid out sum, as there can be no doubt that the money was already transferred elsewhere.  

What is clear is that the decision to help firms quickly was the correct one. Over €2 billion was distributed this way. The fact that the unusual activity of one labor office did not raise red flags, will eventually be investigated and no doubt prosecuted by the respective law enforcement agencies. Another investigation will have to look at the possibility that this was not the only labor office where rules were flaunted. 

This case can serve as a prime example of what can go horribly wrong when speed is paramount and red flags and thorough due diligence cannot or will not be properly carried out. 

So what can be done to prevent such a case from ever happening again? Technology could be the answer. The interconnectedness of government registries, social insurance, and labor office, for example, would have revealed that none of the companies had any employees. These need not be lengthy in-depth due diligence checks, just standardized checklists to make sure the company exists, and it does have money-making activities that require assistance at the time of crisis. The monitoring of office employees also need not be big brother like, with every loo break logged, but perhaps unusually large or outsized claims should require more than just a simple local approval, even at a time of crisis. 

This is an opportune time to highlight and learn from mistakes. There are large investments heading the Slovak way in the form of European structural and investment funds for the program period of 2021 – 2027, as well as a recovery and resilience facility to the tune of billions of euros combined. With both needing to be disbursed quickly, there can be no doubt about effectiveness and accountability. 

- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Latest

Russia failing to replace lucrative European gas deliveries with sales to China

Russia’s attempts to build the Power of Siberia 2...

Astana SCO Summit reaffirms its growing geopolitical role

The 24th summit of the Council of Heads of...

Uzbekistan: A Key Player in the (Central Asian) Great Game

Uzbekistan has had considerable success in attracting billions of...

EU strengthens energy cooperation with Chile, Argentina

This week EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson visited Chile...

Don't miss

Russia failing to replace lucrative European gas deliveries with sales to China

Russia’s attempts to build the Power of Siberia 2...

Astana SCO Summit reaffirms its growing geopolitical role

The 24th summit of the Council of Heads of...

Uzbekistan: A Key Player in the (Central Asian) Great Game

Uzbekistan has had considerable success in attracting billions of...

EU strengthens energy cooperation with Chile, Argentina

This week EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson visited Chile...

Jeffrey Sachs: three times a traitor

An economist with an international reputation, Professor Jeffrey Sachs...

Uzbekistan: A Key Player in the (Central Asian) Great Game

Uzbekistan has had considerable success in attracting billions of dollars of aid, concessional debt, and co-investment, which has helped transform the economy since 2017....

Jeffrey Sachs: three times a traitor

An economist with an international reputation, Professor Jeffrey Sachs has increasingly raised his profile in the world media. A U.S. citizen, he accuses his...

The UK Economy – Another Twist in The Tale

Around the world most nations have been trying to recover their financial strength and where possible find some growth. Above all, they have been...

Genocide Rears its Ugly Head in Sudan’s Brutal War

The UN Security Council has called for a halt to the siege of the city of el-Fasher in the Darfur region, where 1.5 million...

Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan open path for integrating energy systems with the EU

On May 1, during the Tashkent International Investment Forum in Tashkent, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan signed a memorandum of cooperation on merging the energy...

Good news – the UK is not in recession; Bad news – it doesn’t feel like it

One of the greatest problems that both economists and politicians face is the key element of communication. Yes, they may indeed be trying to...

North Macedonia: Resuming course towards the political dark side?

As most analysts predicted after the strong showing of the nationalist presidential candidate in the first-round presidential elections on April 24, VMRO-DPMNE (Internal Macedonian...

A Green 5+1, regional water issues in Central Asia and previewing next year’s Astana International Forum

Kazakhstan’s Astana International Forum (AIF) has been postponed to 2025, as Astana is diverting financial resources to assist the relief efforts after massive flooding hit several regions....